Carmen’s Chatter

A good dictionary will tell us that humility has several different meanings: The first is “the quality of being humble,” which makes me look up humble: “not proud or arrogant, modest”; the second definition listed for humility is “having a feeling of insignificance, inferiority,” and the third is “being courteously respectful.”

So humility can mean anything from “not arrogant” to “feeling inferior” to “being polite,” but that lexicographical diversity doesn’t help me know what the goodness of humility could look like in my life, so I get out the Bible and Andrew Murray’s humility and Benedict’s Rule as practical guidelines.

In the Bible I read that I am supposed to “walk humbly with . . . God” (Micah 6:8), that I am supposed to confess my sin to God, that I should take being wronged patiently, that I should submit to authority, that I should be corrected graciously, that I should accept a lowly place, that I should be grateful for my blessings, that I should forgive, that I should love all people, that I should serve others, and that I should always value Christ above all else.

Andrew Murray writes that humility is a “continuous” and “entire dependence on God.”

And Benedict devotes his longest chapter (seven) to this spiritual discipline. He writes: “The first degree of humility is obedience without delay. This is the virtue of those who hold nothing dearer to them than Christ.”

I am thankful for such good teachers because over the years they have helped to correct my erroneous understanding of humility. I got stuck in definition number two: “a feeling of insignificance, inferiority.”

I used to think that humility was hating my self. No matter how many sermons I heard or how many books I read in which the virtues of my unique, snowflake-like soul’s beauty were extolled, I never quite internally got with that “God-loves-you-and-you’re-beautiful-in-his-sight” program.

I don’t know why, either. I suppose I could flatten myself against a wise counselor’s couch for a few decades and analyze my childhood and my psyche and come up with some sinewy ideas of “why.”

But I suspect that the main reason is that I am a rather tender-hearted human being and therefore I find plenty of reasons to feel uncomfortable with myself just because I am alive and breathing.

I mean—I sometimes forget about the plight of those in Haiti. How can I put one foot in front of the other while there is such suffering in Haiti? Sure, I can donate to the point of not buying cafe lattes at Starbucks for a few weeks, but still.

I mean—how can I for even a moment forget the hungry in my own town and drive down the highway to my various appointments totally immersed in the awesome sounds of Owl City, especially track seven of Ocean Eyes, to the obsessive point that my daughter said to me recently, “Mom, you know I like Owl City, but I’m kind of getting tired of it.”

I mean—I often make mistakes. I can be short with my husband or my children. I can complain about coffee stains left NOT BY ME on my white kitchen countertops.

And, even more incriminating, I often think wrong things inside myself. And I don’t mean “wrong things” in the sense of the-world-tells-me-they-are-wrong. I mean “wrong” in the sense that all human decency and all that is healthy and joyful in this world and the gentle and firm voice of Christ in me says, “Woah, Girlfriend, not good—let go of that poison. Why are you dealing in hatred [or self-pity or criticism of others or envy or grudge-clinging or fear]?”

But now I see that humility is not a total faith in my own lack of worth but is instead a complete dependence on God.

Humility is also not a lack of confidence. It is not self-hatred of any sort. It is also not inviting bullies to turn your heart into a shuttlecock and smack it laughingly over the net of daily life. No.

It is also not selling yourself short inside your soul in soundbites like this: I’m not smart. I’m stupid. I’m worthless. I’m pathetic. I deserve nothing good.

Now I see such thoughts as useless. They aren’t to be condemned as “bad”; they are to be neglected because they are boring and useless. Why did I ever find them interesting? They are as surely a sign of self-absorption as the ugly, strutting kind of arrogance is.

My friend D. W. told me once that if self-absorption were a stick, at one end we find self-loathing and at the other end, arrogance. But both are self-absorption. And neither is a particularly joyful state.

I used to think to myself, Well, at least I’m not arrogant, but now I see that self-loathing is just as awful. I don’t know why I ever found it attractive.

Humility is instead resting in Christ. It is becoming the nothing of love in order to receive the everything of God. It is true intimacy with the divine mystery who is a Person whom we can all know.

Humility is being willing to be taught. Humility is being willing to be open. It is being willing to forgive my self and others, too. It is being willing to remain vulnerable, no matter how often my own immaturity injures me and no matter how many times others accidentally or purposefully wound my heart.

It is so easy to close up then. But I want the humility of a broken, open heart. I crave the humility of the loving, aching soul.

So humility must also be servanthood, the willingness to serve others in love.

This servanthood is not the same as “helping” others. Who wants to be “helped”? I have been helped before when I was down and struggling.

I prefer to be “loved” every time. Love comes alongside you. “Help” comes from above, from a supposedly “superior” creature, but no human being is superior to another. We are all in the same boat, rowing against the wind, trying to love each other in the process.

I want, in short, yes, to be like Jesus, but also to be like my son, John. He is eight. When he was four, I would say to him, “John, you sure are handsome.”

He would answer without hesitation, “I know.” And then he was off to play or to be kind to his sister or to offer to help me take the clothes out of the dryer or to give me a hug, his admission forgotten.

I would marvel. I would contemplate why he could say that with such confidence and with such a lack of self-consciousness. In my friendship with God I have long longed to have such a combination of confidence and un-self-consciousness as my son has in the love my husband and I have for him.

John can answer in that simple but profound statement, “I know,” because he feels completely loved. He totally trusts his father and me. He feels safe in the knowledge that he is part of (yes, imperfect but) a very caring family.

So humility is accepting love. It is considering life from another person’s perspective. Humility is embracing that I am one member of God’s global, non-exclusive family.

Humility is not bitterly grimacing and putting up the neon “CLOSED” sign on my heart. It is accepting moment by moment that God loves me and being kind to my own self. It is also reaching out through my own pain as God nudges me, to love others. It is also not accepting abuse but respecting my self and having healthy boundaries because God loves me.

So “be humble” is an invitation to intimacy with Christ. It is also (to my student’s mind) a huge assignment from the greatest teacher, God. It’s like daily homework. Thankfully, the Holy Spirit is here to help me. Whenever I consider how important humility is and how much I have to learn about it, I realize that humility is the foundation of everything good in this world and that humility is another way of pronouncing the word love.

In class today, my upper-level college students and I were discussing Benedict’s Rule. I am always fascinated by what today’s Facebooking, texting college students find relevant in this timeless, wise work.

Students keep on raising their hands and saying how Benedict’s Rule is an antidote to our “overachieving” lives. Woah. The spiritual principles that Benedict describes are attractive to our brilliant new generation of digerati because these truths teach us how to love our enemies, how to accept God’s love for ourselves and for our own inner “enemies” (you know—our perpetual conflicts of soul that no one but God and we see), and how to become intimate with Christ and so know real peace.

Students are especially drawn to the longest chapter of the Rule, number seven, on humility. Benedict says, “The first degree of humility, then, is that a person keep the fear of God before his or her eyes and beware of ever forgetting it.” We discussed the two kinds of fear—the “alarming” kind and the fear that is “respect” or “reverence.” We are to “respect” and have “reverence” for God, ever mindful that he is Love and that “perfect love casts out all [of the alarming kind of] fear” (1 John 4:18).

In chapter seven, Benedict also recommends this restful approach: “Let us consider that God is always looking at us from heaven, that our actions are everywhere visible to the divine eyes”; what a cheerful difference that would make in our lives.

So I found myself saying to these awesome students that we spend all of our lives trying instead to make sure our resumes are fat and stellar, while our souls remain emaciated and dull, when all along God’s wonder and love are inside us, as Christ reminds us: “The kingdom of God is within” (Luke 17:21).

I told them that if my resume had a category titled “Rest,” it would be a thin category, with few bulleted entries, and that if I were being hired on my experience in resting in God, I would not be hired anywhere. I am not proud of this fact, but admitting it to myself and also out loud started me some time ago on the road of Learning to Rest.

This road is very different from my past way of living. My mode of “rest” has always been to work until I exhausted myself and then to keep on working. I call it “being conscientious.” Some might call it, “not obeying Psalm 46:10,” where we are given very specific divine instructions: “Be still and know that I am God.”

It’s the ultimate homework assignment from the ultimate Teacher: “Rest.” The due date is simple. I have from right now until I am dead to work on it, and I must work on it daily and keep working on it until I take that ultimate (as Mr. Gary Davis calls it) “dirt nap.”

How can we love each other if we have not yet learned to rest in Christ?

That’s the question I ask myself daily: If I learn to rest in Christ and truly rest, how much better will I get at loving God, my self, and others? I am willing to stake my life on trying to answer that question.

I am willing to make myself ultimately vulnerable and open to God in doing so.

Or, as Yoda says, “There is no try. There is only do.” Well, I should quote Yoda accurately. When Luke says to him, “All right, I’ll give it a try,” Yoda tells Luke, “No. Try not. Do. . . . or do not. There is no try.”

Of course, such wonderful, awesome impossibilities are made possible when one’s best friend is Christ, through whom anything is possible, with enough true grit and humility (Philippians 4:13).

All great writers love paronomasia. They are, you could even say, addicted to it.

Paronomasia is not chocolate. It’s just the fifteen-dollar word for “pun.”

And *ahem* it is easy to spell incorrectly because its etymology is para- for “beside” and onoma for “word.” It literally means to juxtapose two different meanings/”words” “beside” each other to create a pleasant vertigo of mind.

Here’s how it looks if we spell it phonetically but without using IPA: “pair-oh-no-MAZE-jah.” That’s cool because it helps us remember that sneaky little “OH” after the “pair” (of words that will be confused on purpose in a well-made pun) and features the word “MAZE,” which every pun creates in our minds.

Even my old dead friend and Benedictine monk from the tenth century in England, Ælfric of Eynsham, loved puns. Of course, his are not knee-slapping joke-type puns; instead, Ælfric uses word play in his sermons to help make his works both enjoyable and memorable for his congregation.

Ælfric’s punning style also helps him to communicate his positive message to his congregation: Jesus saves.

In order to assure his congregation that Christ is both Savior and Healer, Ælfric plays on the Old English word hælu. (Hælu means “salvation” and “health,” even “safety.”)

This works as paronomasia because the word in Old English for “Savior” is Hælend and comes from hælu.

If someone today cheerfully describes himself as “hale,” his adjective has its roots in hælu. Other present-day words that originate in hælu are holy, whole, and health.

Ælfric commonly uses the term “Hælend” for Jesus, meaning “Savior” and “Healer.” In one passage from sermon II, Ælfric plays off these various meanings of hælu, which are italicized and bolded here for clarity: “Hys nama is Hælend, for þan þe he gehælþ his folc, / swa swa se engel cwæþ be him, ær þan þe he acenned wære: / He gehælþ hys folc fram heora synnum” (“His name is ‘Savior,’ because he heals his people, as the angel said about him before he was born: ‘He will save his people from their sins’”) (John C. Pope II.95-97).

This statement could also be translated, “His name is ‘Healer,’ because he saves his people. . . . ‘He will heal his people from their sins.’” Skillful word play communicates the idea that Christ is the divine defender and the divine doctor of his people. (This passage comes from God of Mercy, published by Mercer University Press, 2006).

Other authors have loved paronomasia to keep their writing grounded. For example, E. B. White wrote that “a good farmer” has a good sense of “humus.”

Holly Bradfield, who is never left out of an intelligent conversation, pointed out this excellent pun: “Get that bird a glass of water—he’s perched!” (Magilla Gorilla on Harvey Birdman, Attorney at Law)

At grammar.about.com, I found other examples of paronomasia. Did you know that there is a flower shop in Melbourne, Australia, named “The Lone Hydrangea”?

There is also a beauty salon in London named “Curl Up and Dye.”

There’s also: “Horse lovers are stable people.”

One of my favorites is “Seven days without a pun make one week.”

And, finally, here’s an elegant and eloquent use of a pun: “Peace is much more precious than a piece of land.” (Anwar al-Sadat, speech in Cairo on March 8, 1978)

One of the reasons I love my husband is because he is my best teacher. You may expect me to say that his agape love for me has taught my soul many freedoms, and that is true.

Sean has also introduced me to some of the best books of my life. You don’t soon forget the first day your husband said, “You should look that up in Brewer’s.”

I had asked him where did the expression “Mind your p’s and q’s” come from.

When he recommended I look the phrase up in Brewer’s, I was like, “Brewer’s?” We were newlyweds living in London in the West End district, within walking distance of the British Museum and the British Library.

“You’ve NEVER heard of Brewer’s?” He was plainly astonished.

“Uh, no.”

He went to a shelf in our one-room flat and pulled out a green hard-back book, Brewer’s Dictionary of Phrase & Fable.

Let me digress here to say that everyone should live in a one-room flat in a country not their own their first year of marriage. In 1990, it meant that a) I could not call home and have teary conversations with my mother when Sean and I had a disagreement—too expensive, and b) I could not leave, go to another room in our “home,” and slam a door, ending any discussions. There was only one room in our second-floor flat.

Imagine that. Your first year of marriage in a one-room flat. No bathroom. No escape route. In a city of seven million where you have only a few new friends. Such a setup was a great marriage solvent.

My brand-new British husband, Sean, was twenty-four (to my twenty-nine) and was cuter than any original Beatle, and against a backdrop of seven million strangers and no rooms to retreat to and no mother to cry my heart out to, he kept looking cuter by the minute.

So Sean wanted to show me the joy of this wonderful dictionary. He turned to page 1063 and read the entry for serendipity:

A happy coinage by Horace Walpole to denote the faculty of making lucky and unexpected ‘finds’ by accident. In a letter to Sir Horace Mann (28 January 1754) he says that he formed it on the title of a fairy story, The Three Princes of Serendip, because the princes “were always making discoveries, by accidents and sagacity, of things the were not in quest of.”

And, by the way, “Mind your p’s and q’s” comes from “an admonition to children learning to write to be careful to distinguish between the forms of p and q (although no such admonition was apparently necessary for the equally confusible b and d), or to printers’ apprentices when handling and sorting type.”

When the Counselor comes, whom I will send to you from the Father, the Spirit of truth who goes out from the Father, he will testify about me. (John 15:26)

Nevertheless, I am telling you the truth, it is for your benefit I am going away. For if I do not go away, the Helper will by no means come to you. But if I do go my way, I will send Him to you, and when that one arrives He will give the world convincing evidence concerning sin and concerning righteousness and concerning judgment. (John 16:7-8)

Our friends are some of our best teachers. I am fortunate and my life is inestimably blessed by kind friends who teach me on a regular basis. I have a very awesome friend who is an expert librarian, and she not only shares brilliant book tips with me, but also has a penchant for holding on to excellent phrases and for turning them over in her mind and appreciating them, the way some people do with a fine piece of gold jewelry. A superlative librarian values words, cherishes books, can multi-task, loves people, and knows how to nurture community.

I have a very dear friend who is just like this. She is always reading a good book, always treasuring words, always juggling budget numbers and projects and reports smoothly, and always caring for others. We met at Shorter College years ago, and now Kimmetha ‘Kim’ Herndon is the Director of the Samford University Library. And as anyone at Shorter or at Samford can tell you, Kim is an amazing knitter. I have the coziest booties to prove it, too.

Yesterday Kim introduced me to the invaluable phrase that’s the title of this blog: “Escalation Specialist.” She told me that she was herself introduced to this phrase during something as quotidian and as potentially stressful as negotiating the terms of a purchase over the phone. After her conversation with the entry-level customer service representative didn’t satisfy her questions, she asked to speak to a manager, at which point, she found herself talking to an Escalation Specialist.

Now, honestly, isn’t that a crucial phrase to hug to one’s chest? Escalation Specialist. I told Kim that I have needed that phrase my entire life. How did I live without that phrase for forty-nine years already? I especially needed it during my first year of marriage when Cuban me would take every “discussion” to the “next level,” threatening to turn any marital argument into World War Three. Meanwhile, my kind British husband would say things like, “Um, aren’t you about to start your period? Maybe we can discuss this later?”

I needed an Escalation Specialist.

If I had known that phrase in 1990, in London, as a newlywed, my husband could have teased me, “Hey, we need an Escalation Specialist!” and I could have laughed and dropped my tirade. Well, that’s in my vision of a perfect world.

I do need an Escalation Specialist when dealing with my teenager. I need an Escalation Specialist when encountering traffic in Atlanta as I feel my blood pressure rising when I know I left in plenty of time to get to a talk but still am about to be late because of a car that’s broken down on I-75. I need an Escalation Specialist when dealing with all situations and all people who set my nerves to jangling.

In short, I need an Escalation Specialist anytime I get upset in life. That would be daily. I mean—whose life is ever perfectly aligned with our expectations and hopes? Anyone? Not mine! Even though my mother taught me to count my blessings, I must admit that I also count my unfulfilled, why-hasn’t-this-good-thing-happened-to-me-yet expectations, perhaps even on a more regular basis than I do count my blessings.

To my mind, Escalation Specialist is another name for “Holy Spirit.” I mean that I am learning that whenever I feel my Cuban-brown face turning a bright cherry red or my heart beginning to thump because I’m upset, I turn to Christ’s Holy Spirit within me because He is my Escalation Specialist. He handles escalating fear within me, accepts and forgives escalating anger, understands and comforts escalating doubt, embraces any escalating confusion, accepting in love anything that escalates within my soul—He’s there for me, always.

So I am thankful that there is a wise and loving Escalation Specialist who’s taken up residence in my soul because the Customer Service representative who is my ego is sorely unable to cope smoothly with or resolve the thorny “negotiations” that take place daily in my life.

Kim had another good point. She said that along with an Escalation Specialist, she also thinks a Resolution Specialist would be nice to have on the job. You know—that way the crisis is not only heard and handled but is also neatly resolved, exactly as it “should be.” Ha. I agreed. It would be terrific if life were one tidy resolution after another.

Kim and I both know who the ultimate Resolution Specialist is, but the problem is that my free will is often stubborn and blocks those resolutions that Christ would like to facilitate for me. Still, I am thankful that I have the Holy Spirit as my Escalation Specialist because with his help, this wilful, prone-to-being-defensive, anxious middle-aged human being is moving in the direction of openness, peace, vulnerability, and love.

Thanks, Kim!

I like a good challenge.

I like a good challenge because one day I will be dead, and every day that I do not accept life with an open mind and a vulnerable heart, I have lost precious living time. The best challenge I have ever received from life is how to live with a broken heart without becoming bitter but remaining open and vulnerable and loving and, yes, . . . smiling as I go.

So an image keeps popping up in my mind. It is one of the benefits of having spent nine months of eighteen-hour days immersed in a dead man’s hard work—I mean The Cloud of Unknowing and The Book of Privy Counsel by Anonymous. I spent some 5,000 hours translating his classic writings on Christian contemplative prayer. I adore him, though he is very dead, having left planet earth some six hundred plus years ago.

The image is that of soft leather gloves. I love that image. I think of it every day when I go to my car in the cold of the winter morning. First, I put on my new leather gloves. I bought them at Lenox on one of the trips my teenage daughter cajoled me into making there. I could not resist them. They were so real-leather soft on the outside and so sleekly black and so wonderfully micro-fur-lined on the inside, and they were on sale hugely. So I treated myself to them, and my hands have been toasty warm all through this often unseasonally frigid January in Georgia. I hope they will last me until the end of my life, and I plan to live until 100, so that gives us five decades together, at least.

I have been thinking a lot lately about this particular line in the Book of Privy Counsel about how our souls and our identities should be as flexible and as malleable in God’s will as supple leather gloves are snug on my hands. In my translation of The Book of Privy Counsel (Shambhala Publications, 2009), I have worded it so: “He [God] wants your soul becoming as supple and snug to his will spiritually as a soft kid glove is to your hand physically.”

In the Middle English, this passage reads like this: “He [God] wil haue þee maad as pleying to his wille goostly as a roon gloue to þin honde bodely.” Literally, it is translated so: “He [God] will have you made as flexible to his will spiritually as a Rouen glove is to the hand physically.” (See Phyllis Hodges’s edition of The Book of Privy Counsel, page 168, lines 8-9.)

Our anonymous author is referring to the famous soft leather made in Rouen. Rouen was just across the channel from England, in northern France on the River Seine.

If you look to see how leather was made in the Middle Ages, it will give you pause to see all of those sharp instruments. I am not one for hairshirts because I think enough hurt comes my way when I just try each day to be an honest human being. Haven’t you discovered that, too?

But I couldn’t help but notice these words on that website: stabbing, scratching, stamping, punching, creasing, knives, shears, trenchet, whetstone, needles, hog’s bristles, pincers, and tacks.

As I said, I do not go out of my way to encounter knives of any sort, either physical or metaphorical, such as painful words said to me or injurious acts made against me, but, hey, they do happen; in fact, if I’m not careful, I will go so too-much out of my way to avoid figurative pincers, tacks, needles, shears, and trenchets, that I run the risk of becoming a hardened soul. Oh, then I would flunk Life’s greatest test, which is, it seems to me—Will I die bitter? I mean this—Will I become and live a bitter- and hard-hearted life?

Long ago I prayed to God that if he would deliver me from bitterness each day, that I would do anything to avoid the calcification of my heart. That is why I am hanging on to those words from Anonymous. My heart must become like a fine leather glove from Rouen. Broken. Soft. Pliable. Malleable. Flexible. Loving. Open. Vulnerable. Broken but open. Broken but not bitter. Broken but smiling. Broken but strong. Broken in but not broken down.

That’s the kind of challenge only Christ can make happen. But, hey, I love a good challenge. No superlative teacher gives flabby assignments. This is not a flabby assignment. Live by loving. Keep your heart open, no matter how many times it gets broken. Love as if you’ve never been hurt before. Even love those you do not like and those who have hurt you. Love life, too, even though circumstances such as illness and reverses happen to us all.

Life is still always good. God is still always love. Find the ability to become a smiling broken heart.

Because I want to be a good student of God, I am accepting this assignment and diligently turning my soul to carrying it out. Thankfully, my Teacher is kind and knows where my weaknesses are and comforts me right there, where my heart most needs love. He encourages me daily, even when I slip and fall in spirit or get down about the slow pace of my progress or depth of the darkness of my understanding.

But here is the promise from God: “I will give them an undivided heart and put a new spirit in them; I will remove from them their heart of stone and give them a heart of flesh” (Ezekiel 11:19). I think of this verse every time I put on my leather gloves.

Here is the chapter from my translation of The Book of Privy Counsel that contains this image (I also included the two footnotes).

Chapter 16 from The Book of Privy Counsel (by the anonymous author of The Cloud of Unknowing)
On the joy that is Nothing
From Carmen Butcher’s Cloud of Unknowing with the Book of Privy Counsel

What is this joy like? It keeps your mind from worrying. Nothing will upset you. You would run a thousand miles just to talk with someone else who’s felt this longing, only to discover once there that you’ve got nothing to say to each other because no matter how much you want to say, you can’t say this Nothing. It’s ironic that the topic you most want to discuss leaves you speechless. This joy teaches you an economy of words. Though you are a person of few words, each is deep and warm. Your speech is so mature and full of life that even your shortest sentence will contain a world of wisdom, but anything you say will seem stupid to those who ignore their souls and live only in their intellects. Your silence will be gentle, your speech constructive, your prayers private, your self-esteem pure, your behavior humble, your humor kind, and your joys as simple as a child at play.

You love to be by yourself and sit alone. Others get in the way of this, you feel, unless they’re interested in contemplating with you. You don’t even want to read or hear any books read unless they’re about the joys of contemplation. If this is true for you, then you can be certain that both the interior and exterior signs agree, proving that God is calling you to a deeper relationship with him.

Yes! It’s all true. You’ll see. But what if these vanish one day? I mean what if every shred of evidence you have and every intimate spiritual experience you’ve ever known (as described here) cease for a time? What if you’re abandoned? Or so you think. What if suddenly you realize that you’ve lost not only your new passion for contemplation but also your old dedication to your earlier ways of praying? You’ll feel as if you have fallen down a crack between the two when you lack each and yet remember and miss both. But don’t let your heart grow heavy over this. Don’t be sad or perplexed. Accept this change. Wait patiently on our Lord and on his will for you. Learn humility.

An analogy will help you understand my point. Think of it this way. You’re in a little ship crossing a vast spiritual ocean, leaving behind your focus on the physical and heading towards the life of the spirit.1 Along the way, you’ll meet countless overwhelming storms and endless temptations. You’ll feel alone and depressed, with nowhere to run for help. You’ll think you’ve lost God. Your affections will feel cut off from ordinary grace and special grace. But don’t get too upset. And don’t let yourself be afraid, even though you seem to have good reason; instead, trust our Lord with all your heart. At least put as much faith in him as you can under the difficult circumstances. Remember that God is never far from you. Soon He’ll search you out again and touch your soul more intensely than before, and you’ll feel the warmth of his compassion and contemplative grace.

Then you’ll think you’re whole, completely restored, and all is well, while it lasts—but suddenly, when you least expect it, it will all be gone again, and you’ll find yourself in that boat once more, feeling friendless and rudderless, blown in every direction, tossed here, flung there, not knowing where you are or where you’re heading. But even then don’t get upset, for he will come. I promise. He’ll come very soon, when He finds the time is right, and when he comes, he’ll set you free. Fearless, he delivers you from your sorrow and releases you from your pain, more powerfully than ever before. Believe me when I tell you that as often as he leaves, he will return, and if you handle the interim well (accept it humbly and patiently), you’ll discover that each of his homecomings is stronger and happier than the last. He does this because he wants your soul becoming as supple and snug to his will spiritually as a soft kid glove is to your hand physically.

His goings and comings stretch you, secretly testing your soul, gentling you to do his work.2 During a period when you think God is absent, your enthusiasm will also be gone. You think they’re one and the same thing, but they’re not, and never were. God is merely testing and improving your patience. In difficult times, remember this. Sometimes God may withdraw your joy, your enthusiasm, and your burning desires, but he never takes his grace away from his dedicated friends. I’m equally certain that God’s special grace can never be withdrawn from those who have experienced it and whose lives have been touched by it, unless they committed a mortal sin.

1. This ocean-and-ship analogy, so popular with mystics from the desert fathers and mothers on, is described in great detail by our anonymous author in his letter, Discretion of Stirrings: “I also want to point out that you probably don’t know your inner self as well as you could, but you will eventually. You just lack experience. You’ll understand your temperament and soul better after God lets you experience the ups and downs of life, teaching you much through them. They are a requirement of spiritual growth. No sinner gains self-understanding without them. Temptations, volatile emotions, and difficult experiences buffet us all, and the soul is like a little ship riding the highest waves, through storms and raging seas, until we find safe harbor. Sometimes we have good weather, when the Holy Spirit comforts us, and we’ll know we’ve reached the harbor’s shore when we arrive at the solid knowledge of who we are. Then we’re real, standing in God’s grace.” This translation is my own. See also Walsh, The Pursuit of Wisdom and Other Works by the Author of The Cloud of Unknowing, 135. See Hodgson, ed., The Cloud of Unknowing and The Book of Privy Counselling, 167, lines 14-16.

2. And sith he sumtyme goth and somtyme cometh, therfore doubli in this double werk wol he prively prove thee and worche thee to his owne werk. (“And since he sometimes goes and sometimes comes, therefore doubly in this double work will he secretly test you and work you to his own work.”) The rhetoric’s symmetry and repetition brilliantly communicate the anonymous author’s message here—that the disciple’s life must be a mirror image of the Master’s. Notice the sumtyme goth and somtyme cometh, doubli and double, and werk and worche followed by werk. The rhythm beats against the words in ways reminiscent of the tanning (and softening) of leather. See Hodgson, ed., The Cloud of Unknowing and The Book of Privy Counselling, 168, lines 10-12.

Once, having been asked by the Pharisees when the kingdom of God would come, Jesus replied, “The kingdom of God does not come with your careful observation, nor will people say, ‘Here it is,’ or ‘There it is,’ because the kingdom of God is within you.” (Luke 17:20-21)

This morning at the early 9:00 a.m. service at church, the sermon contained the phrase that is the title of this blog, which is surely worth chewing on for many future hours, days, years, decades.

Hurting people hurt people.

The emphasis is on the “hurt.” Hurting people HURT people. So you have a present participle (”hurting”) used adjectivally to describe the noun “people,” and then take the same verb, “hurt,” and let it function as the actual verb of the sentence.

I guess if you wanted to construct its antithesis, you’d have to use the past participle for “love” as an adjective, to make this sentence:

Loved people love people.

It’s true, too, isn’t it? It is in my experience.

I was thinking how of all the human beings I am fortunate to spend time with on this short-lived ride called Life on Planet Earth, the best one has been and is my husband, Sean.

That’s not to say we go around calling each other “Sweetness and Light,” far from it. We have a real (by which I mean to say–”I took out the trash last”) relationship. And, actually, if Sean reads this blog, he will quickly point out that while I do gather up the trash and the recyclables (and sometimes successfully cajole our children into helping), I usually “let” him crush down the boxes (always from Amazon.com) and actually assemble the trash for the trash can because in the winter it’s just so dastardly cold out there!

Well, but my point is that my husband is both the smartest and the kindest person I’ve ever met. And his unconditional love has of all things on this planet helped me to know what love is. The details are only for me to know, but they are daily and many-layered and always growing.

But back to the “Hurting people hurt people” statement that our pastor made this morning. I think that is profound. I think it has the potential to soften my heart further when someone does something that I find—Woah—painful to my heart.

What if from childhood on, however, we were taught that pain can help shatter our egos and open us up to God? Then the “hurting person who hurts us” would become one of our best friends, always.

We are taught to circle the wagons around our fragile egos so that nothing can disturb either its equanimity (ha) or its strength (double ha). With guns or slingshots or bows and arrows or whatever weapons we have at hand (the jawbone of an ox?), we stand there, hands raised, against all “intruders” who threaten our ego’s status quo.

Woah.

Is it not true for you as it is true for me that my greatest growth in love has come from accepting pain well, even with a smile? I am not talking about something masochistic in spirit. No one wants to hurt.

Nor am I talking about becoming a doormat. No one should become a doormat to others’ cruelty.

I am talking about accepting unfairness well, not letting it torpedo our sense of joy and our sense of peace that should be founded on the everlasting love of Christ, which is always unshaken and unshakeable.

How can we find that? I think we forget who we are. We always ask, or I do, “Who am I?” Finally I have realized deep down (after decades of knowing this truth in my head only) that I am God’s daughter AND a member of the body of Christ. I am both loved by God in the most delicious and abundant way, and I am meant to recklessly love God, my self, and others, that is to say, to be part of community.

I find Christ and his tender-hearted, unshakeable love by sitting in silent prayer and smiling. I find it doing the dishes for my family. I find it by reading and studying the Bible slowly. I find it by memorizing Scripture. I find it by studying the Bible with commentaries in hand. I find it by worshipping with other Christians. I find it by being with my family. I find it by being with my friends. I find it by trying to be kind to all I meet. I find it by praying for others. I find it by remembering to eat healthily (mostly!) and by reminding myself to get sufficient sleep (when my nightsweats don’t interrupt that) and to get some exercise (usually in the form of daily walks). I find it by trying to think what others need. I find it by trying to help those who are struggling in some way. I find it by trying to accept help and love when I am in need and struggling. I find it by doing honest work as best I can. I find it by forgiving those who hurt me and by praying blessings for them (and meaning it). I find it by listening to others and feeling their pain and their joy.

There’s a point. Sometimes we forget that we are supposed to be happy when others accomplish great things. Who hasn’t known this pinprick of the innermost heart? Jealousy is a truly boring, growth-stunting emotion, though, that must be stopped at its first prick because if allowed a toehold in our hearts, jealousy can keep us all chained to the rock of no-compassion with a bird pecking out our livers. (You know about Prometheus and the eagle, right?)

On the other hand, sometimes we forget that we are not supposed to recoil when others hurt but that we are supposed to enter their hurt with them and feel it with them. There is much invisible healing when another person will enter my pain with me and just sit there with me in it.

Hurting people HURT people.

Loved people LOVE people.

Lord, help me be one of the loving ones.

Amen.

While anyone might think that that blog title is oxymoronic, thankfully, that is not true . . . yet. Despite my daughter’s having to put up with a forty-nine-year old mother who dresses like a candidate for What Not to Wear and who thinks that Moby is the first part of the title of a great American novel and not “a successful artist on the ambient electronica scene” (I did my research at Wikipedia—apparently the novelist Melville is, however, a distant relative), my daughter and I do still talk, for which I am constantly on my knees thanking God, literally. And also I am often on the road, literally, driving to Lenox with her in the passenger’s seat.

But you may also be sure that that blog title, “Conversations with a Teenager,” is also a red herring for you, dear reader, because there ain’t no way I’m going to share what we discuss. NO WAY. I am learning that to keep my big mouth greatly shut facilitates conversations.

Also, I think what a terrific sense of humor God must have because He gave peri-menopausal me a thirteen-year-old. Every morning when I take our daughter to middle school, I see car after car with this equally difficult pairing in it—late-forty-something parents driving thirteen- and fourteen-year-olds to middle school.

It is such a study in contrasts, and yet not. Both groups show a decided awkwardness in grappling with that question, “Who am I?” Furthermore, most middle-aged people don’t know anymore who they are in their bodies, for one reason or another. Either they are experiencing the joy of nightsweats or the ecstasy of migraines or the peace of hot flashes or the worry about those extra pounds or the too many gray hairs or the bad back or the aching hip, or they are questioning those familiar eyes as they stare in the mirror, mornings, asking, Who is that old person staring back at me? . . . and the list goes ever on.

Teenagers have a similar unease in their bodies, for entirely different reasons. If middle-age-dom is the gearing down and the wrinkling up and the shrinking in of forty-plus bodies, then teenagers know the awkwardness of being 5′7″ instead of 5′0″ all of a sudden, of becoming young men and young women, of losing their shapes as children and skyrocketing up, with all the aches and pains that the hormones of puberty bring. Wait—middle-age has all that, too, but in reverse.

So by our very natures, we forty-somethings and our teenaged friends are heading in entirely opposite directions. We are standing in a port about to board two different ships, one bound for Antarctica and one for Hawaii. Guess which is which.

Except surely we can still find common ground in listening and in silliness. I do know I score brownie points with my daughter for knowing who her friends are, what sports they play, what classes they share, and what after-school activities they are involved in. I know their names well, thank you. I pay attention to detail.

I also know much about my daughter’s taste in music, and I encourage her to teach dowdy-minded me about some group other than, yes, Pink Floyd. Okay, I love Pink Floyd, Sting, and Fleetwood Mac, but apparently there have been musicians since then, with names like Paramore, Owl City, Muse, Samantha James, Florence and the Machine, Death Cab for Cutie, and others blaring at me in, yes, American Eagle, and when I say “blaring,” I say that with insouciance, for I have actually come to love collapsing in their big brown leather sofa and watching the screen in front of me to learn what new artist is playing; so when my daughter comes out with some of those skinny jeans (said with equal stress on each syllable, I’ve been taught, not SKIH-knee jeans, nor skinny JEANS, but SKINNYJEANS), I can say, “Hey, I just heard Florence and the Machine singing ‘Rabbit Heart.’”

And, woah, if those lyrics aren’t gorgeous.

I have also noticed that silliness can heal a multitude of stress, which includes random dancing moments in the car when no one else is around us and Owl City is awesome in my CD player and earth is turning s-l-o-w-l-y. I love Owl City. When I am ninety, I will still be grateful for how Adam Young brought my daughter and me together over a genuine love of his music.

Well, between praying on my knees—NOT a new thing for me—and looking forward to and even planning regular trips to the Mall—very much a new thing for me—I am learning that prayer remains my best connection to my Best Friend and that Sephora is a makeup store at Lenox where you can buy not only these exquisite makeup brushes for jillions of dollars each but also these little sprays in silver bottles to clean them. (And don’t pull the makeup brush’s soft natural bristles when you are drying them; blot them to make them last longer.) (Oh, and by “Mall,” I mean any mall, mind you, from the decidedly low-key Berry Mall to Phipps, with so many points in between. Thank goodness for a GPS! Like Adam Young, it has nurtured my relationship with my daughter, helping me find any mall within the state of Georgia and beyond!)

So between knee-denting prayer and mind-bending hours spent shopping, I am navigating these years like anyone on a lurching ship would . . . awkwardly. And I keep admitting this fact to my daughter, too.

That seems to help.

Is anybody other than me totally enamored with the poignant stichomythia of texting? I don’t mean I love having to press a button three times to produce a “c” (because I gave my Vu upgrade to my daughter when she turned thirteen, I still have an older, press-four-times-for-z Samsung cell). I mean that I especially love texting’s poetically concise, “to-the-moment” lines alternating between two speakers.

Let me give you an example of this happening today between my friend Beth and me. I’ve known Beth for thirty-one years, and so our texts are usually very short and to the point, the way a spaghetti sauce gets after simmering for a long while; it’s reduced to its essential best taste as all the sweetness inherent in the tomato is brought into the spotlight. Here’s the example:

Me texting in the snowy car line at Rome Middle School: “How you?”

I watch the snow falling.

*30 seconds later* (Hear “30 seconds later” said in the French-type accent of the invisible narrator in Sponge Bob Square Pants.)

Beth texts back: “Good! You?”

Me still in the snowy car line, texting back: “Can you chat?”

Beth: “Sure”

The good, quiet pause indicated above by the asterisked “30 seconds later” always feels exactly like the good, quiet waiting I’ve done in my life with a line in the pond’s water and a red-and-white cork floating above. I feel at peace waiting on Beth to text back, or not. I know she’s there, and that’s all that matters.

If I’m just checking in, to see how Beth is, I especially appreciate how unobtrusive texting is. I think she might be busy, so I don’t call. I text her, to see if she’s around. Then, if she answers by texting me back, I might text her again to see if she’s busy or can we chat, does she have time.

If I don’t hear back anything after the initial inquiry, “How you?” I know that eventually Beth will text me back that evening or the next day or whenever her schedule lets up. After three-plus decades of knowing Beth, I’m convinced that she is one of the kindest people on planet earth and, that said, she will kill me for putting her into another blog.

Anyway, if Beth does text me back in a short time after my initial question, “How you?” I will sometimes ask can she chat, and if she is busy, she’ll text back, “Ltr?” We have this understanding. “Later” is always a possibility, for a garden variety of middle-aged reasons. (We also have an understanding that our calls are always immediately interruptible; if any family member calls, all either of us has to say is, “It’s Kate. Gotta go.” Or, “It’s Sarah. Call you back.”)

Yes, often chats hoped for now happen later also because each of us has a forty-nine-year-old life filled with kids and a husband and other To-Do-List stuff to keep track of. You know—toilets break, trees fall on houses, children have crises, adults have crises, and roofs leak, and I am only referring to the Butcher household here!

But my friend Beth and I also know that if we can have a chat now, we will, because somehow time seems more precious than it was when we were both freshmen at Shorter College riding around through endless days in Beth’s blue MG Midget convertible. We have this knowledge that neither one of us is getting any younger here at the edge of fifty, so we love chatting and catching up on our exciting lives—you know, I say, “Here I am in the car line,” and she says, “My son just got home from school and is throwing a snowball at me.”

Now that I think of it, Beth usually has more to contribute to the conversations. In this one in particular that happened today while I was sitting in the proverbial middle-school car line in a gathering snowstorm (which in the South means at least ten snowflakes have fallen), Beth laughed after I said, “Hey,” and then she added, “It’s funny you call just now because I’m sitting here in front of the fire at station five.”

And then I had a moment of mental vertigo because I heard “station” and thought for a half-a-second of the countless hours that I stood at a bus stop in Seoul with my family, waiting for a bus to take us all over that wonderful city. But, never mind my Pause of Confusion (or POC), for in the approximately 11,315 days of our friendship, Beth has heard many of these POC’s.

In this instance, the POC happened in my head because I had to re-play Beth’s comment on the widescreen TV of my aging mind: “It’s funny you call just now because I’m sitting here in front of the fire at station five,” and only for the briefest moment (I must say) did I picture my friend Beth at a bus stop (on a snowy day?) before I realized what she meant. This mental vertigo is partly occasioned by a constitutional aversion I have to sincere positive statements made in my direction.

Beth meant that when I called she was sitting in front of her cozy fire reading my book, Following Christ: A Lenten Reader to Stretch Your Soul, which just came out a few days ago, and that she was at station five of the Stations of the Cross; and that news made me feel as if the world was alright. If Beth is reading my book, all is well.

But because I have a hard time accepting very cool comments like that, even from such a genuine, tried-and-tested friend, I pretended not to understand Beth’s kind meaning and deflected with a joke: “You mean you’re at a bus stop?”

And she laughed to hear yet another one of my eternal remonstrations: “Silly, I’m reading your book.”

Then Beth added in a tone that sounded almost as if she were incredulous and arguing with someone over the book’s merits: “And I like it.”

I knew who that someone was, too. I knew all that Beth was thinking, so I teased her, “You sound as if you’re trying to convince yourself you like the book. You sound incredulous, as if even you can’t believe you like it.”

“Carmen, you know it’s just you’ve been so wishy-washy about it.”

(I notice her kind selection of diction there in the wishy-washy, not “You’ve been so ‘negative,’” or “You’ve been so ‘fault-finding,’” but “wishy-washy”; this is one reason I love Beth.)

Beth continued, “You know I’m arguing with those past lame statements you’ve made to me about it. I LOVE THIS BOOK!”

Beth is referring to my decades-old now streak of self-doubting. (Granted, a goodly portion of self-doubt makes conscientiousness and endless revising happen in writing, which improves a book, surely.)

But, that said, I am not proud of how often I have experienced the unbalancing effects of self-doubt. I am the Queen of Self-Doubting, even though I know that too much self-doubt is certainly not godly, not Christ-like, not fun to be around if you’re my friend, and makes me prone to working too hard to “prove” myself, which in turn leads to exhaustion and depression. I know that self-doubting is often a synonym for self-absorbed, too.

So I’ve tried to pray it out, fast it out, read-the-Bible-it out, and work it out. I’m still trying. I’m still praying. I’m still reading the Bible. I’m still working hard.

The publisher, mind you, has done an absolutely brilliant job with the book. Kudos to Paraclete Press! But I always read through a book going, I should have said it like this. I should have done it like that. Beth more than anyone knows that. She gets to hear page numbers and specific examples.

Well, Sean also knows it. The first time a box of author’s copies arrived in Seoul, South Korea, where I was teaching at Sogang University, I didn’t open that box for two weeks, in spite of my excitement over having a book published.

My husband finally asked one day, “What’s in that box?”

I was like, “Um, Incandescence?”

*Big sigh on his part.* “And you mean you haven’t opened it yet to look at your book?”

“Um, no.”

“Why?”

“Because I’m sure I’ll find mistakes I’ve made in it?”

“Do you want me to open the box for you?”

“I guess.”

So he did. A good husband like that is hard to find. I am grateful for him.

But back to the stichomythia of—not husband-and-wife dialogue, which I also love—but of regular texting with my friend of three-plus-decades, Beth.

My Hildegard-of-Bingen-like self-doubting and constantly-prone-to-worrying soul are two reasons I love the give-and-take of texting with Beth. Her very existence reminds me of the many good things about life—a priceless friendship is top among them. Beth also reminds me that Jesus loves me. I mean that she is kind to me and also that she often says to me, “God loves you. We have to remember that He means everything for our good.”

That may sound like a simple point, but it’s everything to me. It’s the point I most need to be reminded of.

Now you see why I love the simplicity and immediacy of the stichomythia of texting. It keeps a connection that is thirty-one-years YOUNG alive, leads to positive and supportive and hilarious (YES, especially hilarious) conversations on a regular basis, and keeps me in touch with a friend with whom I’ve walked through sunshiny and also life-is-difficult days.

So that’s why—when a text is coming my way, from Beth, saying, “What’s up?”—I always hope I’m not having to help my husband lug a new super-flush, low-water-usage toilet upstairs or to call the tree specialist about the not-very-light oak leaning precisely on our house or to hand my husband a shingle on the other side of the house where the roof leaks for no reason.

Because, as “iron sharpens iron,” this friend is truly a gift from God and makes my texting back, “Not much,” speak volumes.

Thanks, Beth!

Woah. The last time, dear friend, that I posted a blog was December 17, and I look at that date with incredulity because it is only twenty days ago, as chronological days go; and yet in my soul it feels like twenty years have passed.

Granted, that could partly be because I turned forty-nine over the holidays. It was one of my best birthday days ever, thanks to my husband especially, but, still, any birthday after forty gives me pause. I find myself considering time and the events of my life and thinking, Am I still here?

Is there anyone else out there who has the odd quirk of measuring time by the events in their soul rather than by the teaspoons of minutes and hours and days? Soul events are oceans of non-time, and when I try to put them into the human lingo we call “time,” I think how December 17 was really eons ago and also no-time ago.

Over the break I traveled many places without going anywhere. I can’t say that my soul travels smoothly always, but it does get places. I have decided that I prefer the bumps of an honest road than the gliding along on the arrogance of icy certainty.

Always.

Anyway, I emerged from the sometimes dark, much-soul-traveling holidays to having a box arrive on my porch a few days ago. I opened the box, and out poured light, literally in the form of the books inside from Paraclete Press. They have on their cover the brightest, most spring-inspired orange flower, thanks to IHS Designs and Sr. Mary Lane, CJ.

Yes, this year has started with the bang of having Following Christ: A Lenten Reader to Stretch Your Soul arrive on my doorstep. I fell in love with the cover at once. Mind you, I’d seen it before, but never on the final, published version of the book.

The title, when I read it, goes like this in my mind: Following Christ: A Lenten Reader to Stretch Your [and My] Soul because I need the wise words of these ancient Christian writers very deeply, for healing and for growth and (hopefully) for maturing into truly loving God, my self, and others better with more compassion, which seems synonymous with what we call agape love.

This devotional has the wisdom of the desert Fathers and Mothers, Francis of Assisi, lots of women (and guy) Christian mystics, Thomas a Kempis, Bonaventure, Augustine, Ignatius, Dante, AElfric of Eynsham, the “Dream of the Rood” poet, John Donne, and many others. It is meant to help us walk through the season of Lent, which this year begins on Ash Wednesday, February 17, 2010, and ends with Easter Sunday, on April 4, 2010.

I won’t say more, except that my mother called me today to say that she’d read the introduction and loved it (remember: she is my mother) and that everyone who’s seen the cover loves the cover.

Following Christ: A Lenten Reader to Stretch Your Soul can be ordered from Amazon.com or from the Paraclete Press website. Deep discounts are offered for anyone who orders multiple copies from the Paraclete Press website.

I have just finished talking with John Hall at WORD-FM out of Pittsburgh (101.5 FM, see John & Kathy). We were talking about Christmas and about my list of “top 5″ books to read at Christmas.

The sermons in these books are by the greats from different ages—St. Augustine, Martin Luther, St. Thomas Aquinas, Bernard of Clairvaux, and Dietrich Bonhoeffer. But they all make the same point: It is amazing that God humbled himself and came to earth as a human baby.

As a soul in dirt mixed with stardust, I find it difficult to grasp that the divine Mystery, the ultimate Being, the Spirit of our loving God assumed what a friend of mine calls this “body of humiliation.” You know what she means. We are all so prone to break down, wear out, forget, do wrong.

In one of these books, St. Augustine calls the miracle of the incarnation the Verbum infans, “the unspeaking infant Word.” That gets my attention—the divine Word of John 1:1 born as a baby who has no words.

I work in words 24/7/365. The wordless Word gives me great hope that I can find the Way by trusting in Jesus with a childlike faith. I don’t have to write it just right or even live it just right (though I wish I could)—I just have to turn my stubborn will to God for help, for healing. For who doesn’t have a wounded soul?

In another of my “top 5″ Christmas books, Martin Luther talks about the accessibility of the divine naked baby. I think he means for us to notice that God made himself vulnerable to us. Isn’t that the hardest thing to do as a human? It is for me. Everytime I make myself vulnerable to God or to another person by confessing my weakness or admitting my mistake, I cringe first and keep on cringing. It is not easy to enter the manger of humility, to expose our naked need to God, to feel the straw of remorse puncturing our pride.

Luther’s sermon reminds me of the many times I have told God my ugly, immature thoughts and desires. I just turn around in my chair in my office and put my elbows on my knees and my face in my hands and *sigh* and look out the window at the fountain and the blue sky beyond it and talk to God, just as I am blogging to you. Only when I talk to God, I tell him everything. Everything. Then I ask to be forgiven and to become less tight-fisted of heart and more loving. I ask God to help me do the things I cannot do alone.

In another of my “top 5″ books for Christmas, Thomas Aquinas’s prayers focus our hearts on the Lord and help us become more intimate with Christ. In another, Bernard of Clairvaux focuses on the Christmas message of “brotherly love.” They remind us that our love must be active, that it must reach out to others in need and companionship. Love must be practical; it must act kindly.

In a book of Dietrich Bonhoeffer sermons, this German minister says that Christmas is best celebrated by those “troubled in soul.” I am one of those people. I am troubled in soul. I am in need of God’s healing touch. Daily. By the second. Every time I fail, I am reminded that only Christ can make me whole.

Therefore, this Christmas I am celebrating the birth of Jesus consciously, attentively, even desperately, in my heart, and with my family here. There are decorations and gifts and such here at our home, but there is little fanfare, just as there was little fanfare in the stable, where horses and cows munched their hay.

And there is vulnerability. I am trying to make myself as vulnerable to God as God made himself vulnerable to me by being born as a naked baby into a world of poverty, war, temptation, greed, and hunger. Hunger of all types. And loneliness. And betrayal. And misunderstandings. And heartache of every sort. I have to be vulnerable to all of these things, by which I mean—I must accept them in grace.

What Christmas says to me is that Jesus knows it all. He even knows that most desperate feeling of abandonment, for that little baby grows up to cry on a horrible cross, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” There are situations in this world where we turn to God in our desperation and have only that to offer him. He takes it, too, and gives us back an inexplicable peace.

The manger and the cross are superimposed images, in my mind. I don’t have one without the other. Both are images of humility. The first is the most non-celebrity event anyone can imagine. Cows don’t have cameras. Horses don’t Facebook. The second is the worst death imaginable and the most shameful in the Roman empire. From poverty to shame, Jesus—that little baby—will cover it all.

I also read in the Bible that Jesus was tempted as we all are, yet without sin. That comforts me tremendously. So he knows my every weakness and my every sadness, but he did not succumb; and so I can turn to him in my darkest difficulties of soul, for strength.

I also see that Jesus had friends, and here is where I am most grateful this Christmas as I celebrate the birth of Christ. As God-in-man, while on earth, Jesus lives out the joy of friendship. My friends are priceless. They go to depths in my heart that I can’t even put into words. They bring God’s mercy into my life when I cannot see the road ahead. They make the journey worthwhile. They stand by me when the way is hard. Jesus had friends, too, and he knows what I’m talking about.

This Christmas, I am asking God to help me do as Martin Luther says in one of his sermons: I want to celebrate Christmas every day of the year, not just once in December. I need the joy of this season on a daily basis.

I start by praying that God will make my heart larger, like the Grinch’s in that Dr. Seuss Christmas special.

So I bring my “troubled soul” to the manger and there lay down my burdens and my sadness and my sinfulness and my will as my only gifts, in front of that divine baby nestled there in the hay, for he is my savior, my best friend, and my counselor.

Amen.

My friend and an awesome musician, mom, organizer of great community-building activities, and ETC., Ann Boyd, sent me a-link-to-end-all-links in response to my last blog; it is such a terrific response that I post it for you, my Internet-savvy digerati friends here and here and here. Thanks, Ann!

I read looking for answers.

By the dozens, I read books, others’ blogs, student essays, articles by colleagues in academic journals, newspaper columns, online pieces—you name it. I am looking for answers, for peace, for rest for my soul.

Can you separate your thoughts from your feelings, your feelings from your thoughts? Shouldn’t all of our most analytical thoughts be kind and all of our deepest and most secret feelings worthy of Phi Beta Kappa?

No matter how well-written, how brilliant, how insightful, and how helpful a piece of writing is, reading filters experience. I do love that filtered experience, but sometimes I think the best blog would say: “Sit there. Be. Listen to the fountain outside your window.” Or even: “Stop trying so hard. Go get a cup of coffee. Talk with Gary Davis. Be.”

Stop looking for your self in words. Go live. Dare to be loving.

I never seem to have enough time. Now this is a funny statement because I always have the same amount of time every day, so why do I feel I am short of time always? No, actually, sometimes I feel as if I have too much time on my hands. When I’m waiting on something I want NOW, time is a turtle. That “something” doesn’t have to be world peace, either. Ever watch me in the Chick-Fil-A drive-through waiting on something as simple as a chocolate shake? It’s stupid to be that impatient, but I can be, on a bad day.

Regardless, it’s not as if one day I wake up, check my Time Chart to see “Today you’ll have three hours,” and the next day see “Today you’ll have 3,000 hours.” No. Every day I have twenty-four hours.

So apparently I have a time management problem. Or perhaps more accurately I have a time cherishing problem. My minutes seem either to slip away or crawl away. They rarely just are.

The best timelessness I’ve ever known is in writing. No. That’s not true. I remember time stopping seeing Kate for the first time, covered in that white vernix coating newborns have. Tears and time stopping seem to go together. And I remember time stopping when John got off that plane from Korea; he was in my arms, and I hugged him forever—he smelled like baby pee and sour-milk spitup and was brown and soft against my chest. Hugs and time stopping seem to go together. And I remember time stopping when my fiance, Sean, pulled me off a sidewalk in London’s Bond Street shopping district and kissed me hard in an alleyway near Garrard’s jewelry shop, and I kissed him back in a city of seven million reduced to two. Definitely kisses and time stopping go together.

If I cherished time more, wouldn’t timelessness be the norm? Timelessness always breaks in when I’m not in a rush, when I’m open to the cup of coffee I’m drinking or the toothbrush I’m holding or the son whose ear I’m kissing or the teenager I’m listening to. By being receptive to them, my soul dissolves in attention directed outward. Every day this and that is timeless. That granola bar. This friend talking. That lunch with Gary Davis. This crispy french fry Sean cooked. That student asking me about how to apply for a Fulbright grant. This Owl City Fireflies song about earth turning slowly.

Writing, when done right, is a constant dissolving. Loving is a constant dissolving. The question is how do we survive this dissolving.

As humans how do we stay vulnerable and also strong?

Experts on intercultural communication talk about “tip-of-the-iceberg” cultural traits versus “bottom-of-the-iceberg” or “below-the-waterline” cultural traits. Clothes, gestures, language, and such are the one-fifth “tip,” while beliefs, attitudes, learning styles, values, and such are the four-fifths hidden.

Can’t the same be said of people? (I’ve always thought each person represents his or her own “culture.” That’s why discussing “intercultural communication” is always so difficult. We use large categories to describe it—lots of “do’s and “do not’s”—all the while knowing simple categories are consistently surprised by the idiosyncracies of individuals and individual groups within each culture.)

Isn’t each person about one-fifth showing and four-fifths hidden? That one-fifth should definitely look humble, as Benedict of Nursia suggests. For me, I simply look to my husband to see what that would look like and try to copy him. Sean is not loud, has a humble bearing even in his walk, does not jump to conclusions, is always kind, does not easily take offense, and looks for the good in others.

The four-fifths should also be humble. That’s what I’ve been studying lately—how to pray. It seems that prayer is, as author Roberta Bondi likes to say, “warfare to the last breath.” She spent much of her time as a professor at Emory studying the ancient Christian writers, and they, too, write that prayer is “warfare.” They mean inner warfare, where we struggle with our selves.

I have just read Frederica Mathewes-Green’s book on the Jesus Prayer (Paraclete Press, October 1, 2009). It is a life-changing book. It explains the Jesus Prayer in deceptively simple, compassion-rich, gentle, wise, and inviting prose. I first read Das Jesusgebet (The Jesus Prayer) when I was 22 and in Germany. My octogenarian German friend Mother Buschbeck gave me a copy for Christmas.

I was taken with it. It helped me through a hard time. I especially liked the idea that you gather up momentum in prayer, “like a bird soaring in the sky,” which flaps its wings over and again until it reaches cruising speed and can ride a thermal. See under “Soaring” here. I started trying the Jesus Prayer as I walked beside the Neckar River in Heidelberg. But then I must have forgotten it or simply got involved in other things and let it go.

During graduate school I turned instead instinctively (without knowing what to call it) to what I didn’t know was lectio divina. First, I read the Bible through several times in a fairly short, intense period of cerebral time, using The Expositor’s Bible Commentaries. It was intense, and wonderful. I was suffering from huge insomnia and depression at the time, but I soldiered on, studying English thoroughly in graduate school, somehow (was a miracle) making Phi Beta Kappa and somehow (was another miracle) receiving a Fulbright to the University of London and also every morning and throughout the day studying the Bible.

I was also walking two hours a day, one in the morning and one in the afternoon. These times of walking helped me digest all that I was learning, both in the classroom and in my small apartment. Walking helped pack in and arrange the information in my mind, so I could take more in. Walking has always been essential to my sanity. Huge chunks of hours spent walking have always been my companion.

Bible study became an obsession. Not that I told anyone. I just did it because I could not not do it. I was so hungry for the Bible. That has never left me. I would type up (yes, type) Bible verses on 3″ x 5″ cards and discreetly carry them with me. But, unlike some of the addictive things humans use to numb pain, my 3″ x 5″ Bible verses helped me—not to avoid my pain—but to walk through it.

I do still carry Bible verses around. I eat them. I take them in. I mull over each word. I let one word speak to me. Then another. Then a phrase. I read the verses again. Then I sit with them. Or I walk with them. I often walk and “read” the Bible. Finally I ask the Lord, “What are these verses saying that I must do? What must I do? How must I change? Help me, please.” Then I digest them.

I have never followed four steps lectio divina. My approach, done instinctively, has always been more web-like, more organic, less a system, more a process of discovery, this way and that. The main thing is that I eat the verse or verses. I eat the words. I eat the Word.

I’m from Canton, Georgia. No one taught me lectio divina. I had never heard that phrase when I began practicing it. The earliest Christian writers understood my instinctive “web-like” (non 1-2-3-4) approach to “sacred reading” (lectio divina), for they practiced it, too, before everything came to be outlined and categorized. Categories aren’t bad, but they give the impression that things of the soul always progress linearly, and we all know from experience that that’s just not true or even to be recommended.

Matthew 11:28-30 are an example. Now I have those verses more-than-memorized. They are in my soul. I have gone over them in my mind so very much that they have become part of the fabric of my interior. I thank God for that.

“Come unto me” is such an intimate invitation. It’s something my husband would say to me. It’s something I would say to my son or daughter. And the invitation is open-ended: “ALL YOU,” and who isn’t “weary and burdened”? I ask you that.

And there is a promise: “And I will give you rest.” Not a homework assignment. Not a talking-to. Not a hassle. Not the experience of being put on hold. No. “Rest.”

Then He tells us to take His yoke on us (and since yokes were often double, the idea is that we are alongside Jesus) and “learn from me.” I get that—Jesus is supposed to be my Teacher. I love that.

What can He teach me? If I’m looking to sing in the Shorter College Chorale, I’m going to watch Dr. Martha Shaw conduct and see what she has to offer me, and it would only take attending one concert to see her throw open her arms and hear that heavenly music come from the awesome Chorale to convince me that I want to learn with and from Dr. Shaw.

What is it that Jesus can teach me? Look at His life. He can teach me gentleness and humility, both qualities I desperately need, daily: Jesus says, “Learn from me because I am gentle and humble in heart.”

“And you will find rest for your souls.” He says again that He’ll give us rest. His rest. He reminds us that His yoke is easy and His burden is light. He wants to swap His yoke and His burden for my approaches that simply don’t work and for my burdens that simply overwhelm me.

I also pray the Jesus Prayer now again. I started researching it again a year ago. Then, oddly, a good friend called me to say she’s writing a book translating the Jesus Prayer. In between all that I translated The Cloud of Unknowing for Shambhala and lived in that author’s world of contemplative prayer.

I have found the Jesus Prayer works well with my OCD nature. Throughout the day, I pray, “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.” It’s not a mantra. It’s an invocation. It’s my turning to Christ for conversation. It means I’m listening to Jesus and accepting His love. It’s my prayer to Jesus, the Son of God. I pray it throughout the day. It helps me fight the battles of the mind. When thoughts assail me (and they do), I turn to Christ with the Jesus Prayer, and I find peace. It is good medicine. And it tastes as sweet as honey.

Prayer is the four-fifths of my hidden life that helps me work out the meaning of this Bible verse: “And be transformed by the renewing of your mind” (Romans 12:2).

I worship communally, I study the Bible in great and much-needed depth, I pray in different ways (intercessorily, with gratitude, contemplatively, in the Jesus Prayer, etc.), and I try to serve others to the best of my flawed and clay-footed abilities.

I hope to grow in love. I hope that I can purify my inner woman (my soul) in grace, through the empowering love of Jesus Christ. My inner woman (that four-fifths of my soul that is below-the-waterline) needs the ceaseless, ongoing application of and engaging in and acceptance of the grace of God so that my one-fifth of service and other visible behaviors might bring Christ glory in LOVE.

Amen.

I just read Fearless by Max Lucado because a Shorter graduate recommended it to me, and this book was very worthwhile indeed, easy to read while being both comforting and challenging. It caused me to write a few new 3″x5″ index cards, my favorite being this one:

Jesus said to them immediately, “Don’t be afraid. Take courage. I am here!” (Matthew 14:27)

So seriously, that is beautiful, especially the “I am here!”

If only I could learn not to forget that.

“I am here!” in the middle of my raising a teenager.

“I am here!” in the middle of my worries when I am editing a book.

“I am here!” in the middle of deadlines.

“I am here!” in the middle of my wondering how to love difficult people better.

“I am here!” in the middle of my trying to learn how I myself can change so that I am not one of those difficult people!

“I am here!” in the middle of my intercessory prayers for my friends who have real problems.

“I am here!” in the middle of my trying to teach students well and from a whole perspective.

“I am here!” in the middle of global financial crises.

“I am here!” in the middle of my trying to grow up, daily.

“I am here!” Jesus says.

I just need to listen and let that be true for me.

The other day I was in Dr. Martha Shaw’s office, and she was making me a cup of coffee. And when I say “coffee,” I mean hot, dark, real, and perfectly doctored with steamed milk. And when I say “office,” I mean a very classy place with subtly pink walls and a great view of the piazza in front of Sheffield-Thompson, with fountain and flowers.

So I am sitting there thinking how awesome is it that Dr. Shaw (THE Dr. Shaw) is making me a hot cup of coffee in her cool office, and then she hands it to me in a beautiful, delicate floral cup and makes herself one; and then we start having one of our magical chats, like this. I say something long and long-winded and convoluted and impossibly baroque in description, and then I realize that my being at ease with Martha has made me use fifteen words where one would have done nicely; when I finally stop my tilting-at-windmills speech to look at Martha and gauge her reaction, I notice she’s gotten very quiet, and that’s the magical part because then she says, “I know what you mean” (just when I think she should be thinking, “You’re a lunatic, Carmen”).

So here’s what we were talking about that day, in as few words as I can muster. Shorter College is a special place. Never mind that yesterday when my husband needed to put up a sign about the online program he had to get his masonry drill out and drill into the packed red clay and bedrock that the college is founded on—all that in order to get the metal legs of his sign planted firmly in the ground. Seriously, Sean is Director of the Online Program at Shorter, and his experience shows how Shorter is definitely founded on “The Rock.” We simply call it “The Hill.”

The Hill is a special place to be. I walk around the Hill often at 7:30 in the morning after I drop off our son at school. Lately I have Matthew 11:28-30 with me. It’s typed up in twenty-four-size font so I can read it without my glasses. I do have it memorized, but I still carry it around with me when I walk so I can read it and see those comforting words and dwell on them, and hope and pray they saturate my soul with their peace and strength.

I often walk around the Hill at lunchtime (if not in the morning) and in the late evening, sometimes with my family. I would like a dollar for every time I have walked around the Hill. I’m sure I could fund a scholarship for a deserving high school student, for FOUR YEARS.

So here’s the thing about Shorter. You walk around the Hill, and you notice it’s not big. The scenery doesn’t change all that much. We have 150 acres, most of it up on that Hill, and yet. Every day the scenery changes to the discerning eye. The oaks are huge, their bark is rough to the touch, and their leaves are massive and comforting. Now, their leaves move quietly in the wind and are as green as inchworms or pastel pool floats, but in fall their leaves will rattle against the sky; and I will bring my children out to hear them, as I have every year. Then in winter the old tree stands there with its limbs bare and lifted up to the sky, reminding me that less can be beautiful and that simplicity always pleases God.

Meanwhile, the pines are never the same, either. “Evergreen” doesn’t mean “ever-the-same.” I love pines for their ordinariness. They are easy to overlook, but once you catch the knack of noticing them, they can surprise you with their beauty. I think that if you could say pines have a temperament, they would be shy. You have to earn your way into their trust. Sometimes they lean in the wind this way, sometimes that way. Sometimes birds sit up in them, sometimes not. They lose limbs in storms. At different times of day, their green is darker, and sometimes there’s lots of brown pine straw in a certain spot in one of the parking lots, sometimes not so much.

The clouds? I tell you. The clouds pretty much rock our Hill. They are never the same. When I was writing The Cloud of Unknowing, I noticed clouds a whole lot more, and that habit has not gone away since. They seem to speak to me of God’s love and of his mysteriously intimate presence in my life. Sometimes the clouds from the Hill are as huge as any Abraham might have seen; sometimes they disappear altogether. You never know. And then when the rains come, as they did today, blowing over our Hill, they change all of nature there.

The Hill is always changing, from lush greens of summer to the goldens of autumn to the simplicity of winter and back to the tender greens of spring. Coach Ricci Lattanzi likes to say that the sky is “Shorter blue,” and I agree. Walk around the Hill often enough, and you’ll see for yourself.

I said all of this to Martha and more. I told her how when I walked around Shorter or just worked there in my office I always feel as if this is a special place, as if many people have prayed on this Hill, for many years. Also, cannons were fired off this Hill during the Civil War; maybe people died during those battles here. You can see a place where the soldiers dug a flat spot for a cannon. A treasure-hunter told me that once in Chick-Fil-A when he spotted my “GO, HAWKS” t-shirt. I can show it to you.

I told Martha that it seems to me that no prayer ever prayed on the Hill has ever been lost, that the accumulated prayers of others for Shorter, Rome, and the world beyond the Hill seem to cling to the pines and the red dirt at Shorter. I may be imagining it, but my heart says I am not. I have felt this feeling before when I am in Europe in a cathedral or in certain churches or on an Indian mound out in the remotest woods; these are places where people have gathered, speaking in hushed, awed tones.

You can feel those many prayers that have been prayed on the Hill. It gives me hope for the feeble ones I send upward. That they will linger. That a student who needs to feel them one day, will. For when I pray Matthew 11:28-30, I am also praying it for Shorter College and for all who are part of “the Hill.”

Also, the beauty of the place is large, and I think of the Psalm that says, “The earth is telling the glory of God.” Shorter does that. Just walk around it once. Surely someone will stop and offer you a ride (like Joan Ledbetter, who does go at least 55 up that S-curve, easily). When you shake your head and say, “Just walking for my health,” they will know your secret. They will know you are walking for the God of it, for the prayers you can pray, for the silence you can hear, for the pines you can see, for the air you can breathe, and for the Christ you can adore.

When I said all that to Martha, she shook her head once yes and said, “I’ve felt that, too.”

So can you. So, welcome freshmen, and welcome back, sophomores, juniors, and seniors. We are proud of you. We are thankful for you, and we look forward to learning together . . . on the Hill.

Selah.

I heard a sermon this morning on these verses. They dovetailed nicely with the Psalms I have been reading lately, especially Psalm 55.

So here’s the deal. Isn’t it easy to sit back in church while the preacher is enumerating the six or seven things God hates? Okay, so God hates arrogance and a lying tongue and those who bear false witness and those who run to watch a fight and cheer it on and those who make plans against others for harming them and those who stir up trouble among friends and those who maim or kill others, both physically and soul-wise.

That’s not me. (That’s what my soul says as I listen.) And then it lists off several top candidates for people being adumbrated by the wise Psalmist.

But then my heart says, Dang, that is me. And that’s me, too. And that.

Another writer of ancient wisdom says, “Count it all joy.” All of it?

You have got to be kidding. Count problems joy? Count trips to the doctor joy? Count being slandered joy? Count running into those with tongues as sharp as razors joy? Count dealing day in and day out with my own sack of dung-like neuroses joy? Count my inner paralysis joy? Count problems with friends joy? Count dealings with liars joy? Count dealing with my own lying joy?

You have got to be kidding.

But what if I could. What if I could reach such equanimity of soul?

Would I still be Cuban? Smile.

I would die to have such peace.

I guess that is the point.

Dying to self is something I grew up hearing about. I no longer equate it with self-loathing. I see self-loathing as a bad thing, something to be “shut of,” as a wise old person might say in Mountainese.

But dying to self is a grand adventure, filled with accepting God’s love and entering into the mystery of suffering and the pain of affliction and transforming them in Christ’s grace.

I get so weary of my problems. By that I mean mostly that I get weary of my soul’s issues, above all other difficulties life hands me. Sometimes I think of my self as that dog in proverbs said to always be returning to his own vomit–I am the fool (Proverbs 26:11). If I could soothe my own soul first, the problems that others transfer onto me would be far less of a perceived annoyance.

It’s why I translated The Cloud of Unknowing, to get nourishment for my soul. It’s why I read the Bible, to feed my hungry heart. It’s why I pray and try to listen to God and work to be kinder to my family and to those with whom my life intertwines, so my parched self can drink from that divine water.

Lord, help me, help us all to become more available to you.

Tag, you’re it!

I’m working on getting a Twitter “Follow Me” button up on my website, but, until then, here’s my Twitter name, carmenbutcher. Come follow along! All are invited!

I have to say that I want to make sure my Twitter button says, “Follow Me on Twitter,” not just “Follow Me” because that second option always reminds me of Jesus’s words to the fishermen; therefore, their use is singular in my mind.

My best friend, Beth, said tonight over the phone that the only real success is in how much we experience the presence of God in our lives, or maybe she said success is how much we recognize God’s presence in our lives. I wish I could remember just how she said it.

She also talked about how “sorrow and suffering” always arrive with a sweet fragrance in the allegory Hinds’ Feet on High Places because God is there, present in them. So.

I decided that even though I would like my life to be a bed of roses, and even though I would like not to have a hard time, my life is not a bed of roses, and I do have hard times; I must learn to accept life’s “sorrow and suffering” and experience God in them so that they are transmuted into Love.

Love. I do think if I get quiet enough internally, I can, in God’s grace, do this.

Enter the silence. Live there. It’s my new desire.

Why not try.